Skip to main content

Research Concerning My Medal's Value: Findings of the Value of Gold and The Great War

 

 


[1]

After receiving my medal back in 2019 as a collegiate track runner, I did not place much thought into what its components are. I was, however, very pleased to have won it, and now that I am in Dr. Bruggeman’s Material Culture course, I am on the hunt to discover what my medal consists of. To gain potentially fruitful results of a CAA medal’s structure, I should reach out to the organizers of the CAA activities to gain an idea of what the process to form a CAA medal is and what elements would be found in the medal. For the time being, for this week’s analysis on my CAA medal, I chose to analyze medals in broad terms of object biography. I concentrated on the decades of the 20th century before the Great War as well as the postwar decades to research the precious metal, gold: a metal which is often found in commemorative medals like mine.

While researching the value of gold in decades surrounding the Great War, one of my strategies was to find the current monetary value of a gold WWI medal awarded to an American citizen during the Great War and postwar era. After a few search terms and avenues of research, I came across a medal of interest which also seemed telling of how other American Great War medals like it might be monetarily valued. The medal was a Gold Star Mother Pilgrimage Medal on a website called “First Class Coins”. To provide my reasoning for my excitement of having found this medal, The Gold Star Mothers of the U.S. postwar years were American women who traveled to France to commemorate the combatants who were buried on French land. Since I am researching the commemoration of Black WWI veterans and Black women with relatives who served in the war made this pilgrimage, this find was quite significant and nice to have come across!

This particular medal is described by the seller as being “bronze with a gold star”, and though the majority of it may not be gold, the gold star contains the precious metal I have interest in[2]. Whether this medal is an authentic medal is not in my expertise, but it is currently being placed as purchasable at $275. From my other searches on e-commerce websites like Amazon and eBay and my searches via Google’s search engine, a lot of Great war replica medals were priced at no more than $20 dollars. This being said, medals that are labeled as authentic on these websites are within a very similar price range to that of the Gold Star Mother Pilgrimage medal which grabbed my attention ($200, $300, $400). From my research findings, I would think that if a Great War medal is deemed to be “authentic”, I would peg it to cost no less than $100 dollars. I do not intend to place my calculation of this medal over others, nor do I claim to be an expert on calculating its monetary value. I will, however, continue to research the social and economic value placed on said medals both in the era in which Americans received them and how Americans tend to price and value them in contemporary times. This search also helps me to reflect on the authenticity of my own medal. Is it real gold? Does it contain any element of gold? Hopefully, I can contact members of the CAA, but until then, it is, and always will be one of my most valued possessions.

 I also tracked down some very interesting monographs and articles which focused on Gold as well as the war’s impact on gold as a monetary value. In one of these articles titled The Gold Standard published by British professor and economist J.H., Jones provides insight as to how nations involved with the Great War valued gold as a means of transaction in prewar years and his perception of the decline of gold as an efficient and valued currency. Jones notes that gold was of great value in the turn of the 19th century, yet during the war its value declined and nations like Britain and the U.S. struggled in prewar years to use the value of gold for financial gain in postwar years[3]. Though the article did not bring into conversation the value of gold medals per say, I did find it enlightening in terms of the broad value of gold in the U.S. and Britain. The views of an academic like J.H. Jones and his perception of the value of gold and the U.S.’ economic situation in terms of gold as an economic factor was something I found to be educational.

 


[3] J. H. Jones, The Gold Standard, (The Economic Journal 43, no. 172 1933): 553-554. Accessed March 9, 2021. doi:10.2307/2224503.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Post #10: How Can We Promote Diversity and Cordialness In Archival Spaces?

  In the article What’s Wrong with Digital Stewardship: Evaluating the Organization of Digital Preservation Programs from Practitioners’ Perspectives (2020), a study conducted in 2018 unveiled certain issues that archival practitioners found to be hindering the staffing and efficiency of their program’s digital preservation methods. Amongst the thoughts expressed by the participants via interview were concerns about microaggressions, prejudice, and misogyny within their work environments. [1] Though incidents of misogynistic and prejudice behavior are found in a multitude of career pathways, many archives and special collection practitioners today push for diversity of staff within their work and research spaces. In one of these interviews, an anonymous participant pointed out a negative factor of the nature of tenure. The participant stated that due to the tenured status of the practitioner they work with, when they hear said staff member making misogynistic comments towards othe...
Post a Comment
Read more

Post #6: Being Attentive to Culturally-Sensitive Collections in Special Collection and Archival Spaces

  In Ellen M. Ryan’s Identifying Culturally Sensitive American Indian Material in a Non-tribal Institution (2014), the accessibility to the contents of a collection pertaining to the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes of the Fort Hall Reservation in Idaho found within the Special Collections and Archives of Idaho State University are called into question. This collection, the “J.A. Youngren Papers,” includes photographs of Shoshone-Bannock practices such as the “Sun Dance” (a ceremony of the Great Plains tribes) taken and acquired by the university in the early 20 th century without the consent of Shoshone-Bannock members. [1] In 2013, an undergraduate student and sun dancer tasked with processing and housing these photographs took note of the rituals captured within the photographs and the problematic nature of displaying these photographs online without the consent of tribal members. He thus brought this concern up to the Head of Special Collections of ISU and the photos were soon after ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Post #9: Examining Avenues for Archival Outreach to the Public

  This week, my classmates and I discussed the myriad of ways that archival and special collections staff can advocate for the vitalness of their work as well as the ways that they may take action to connect with the public through outreach activities. This conversation reminded me of the appraisal activity that I completed while at Temple’s SCRC this past October. During this activity, I looked through the “Arthur Hall Papers”: a collection that contained papers and documents about the renowned choreographer of African dance, Arthur Hall, who traveled around Philadelphia to teach young children African dance within schools and other spaces of youth learning. With the size of Philadelphia and the variety of programs that take place today centered on youth learning and community activities, could collections like the Arthur Hall Papers be utilized to show Temple’s surrounding communities how the SCRC’s retainment of papers like these are integral to the success and fruitfulness of f...
Post a Comment
Read more